This is a fun--almost beer and pretzels--game with a crazy pirate theme that, despite my initial doubts, manages to deliver a very solid gaming experience. Though I generally prefer more historical games, Rum and Bones Second Tide is a well crafted design--with solid rules, excellent components and a game length that won't overstay its welcome. Looking forward to expanding the mix a bit and I intend to keep this one on the shelf to keep Robinson Crusoe and Merchants and Marauders company in the shipwrecks and pirates section.