Meet the Contributors

Receive the latest posts directly to your inbox every week!

Sign Up Now

Mare Nostrum: Empires Review

Charlie & Craig

What does this rating mean?

Posted by Charlie & Craig on Aug 23, 2016

Charlie:

Craig:

CT: Mare Nostrum: Empires is the second recent Academy Games Kickstarter release that hearkens back to old waters, unearthing an out of print game and revamping it for the modern age. While I may not have any experience with the original Mare Nostrum, I can’t help but be impressed with this heavily streamlined civilization game. We’re talking 3-5 players with economic expansion, cultural development, and military conquest all in about 90-120 minutes. That’s like the holy grail of contemporary civilization-style design.

CC: Mare Nostrum’s streamlining is definitely its key feature, and I’m most impressed with how fast the production/trading portion of each turn moves, while still giving the feel of managing a unique civilization. Civ games these days seem to focus on shaving down each X except eXploit, but Academy Games manages to buck that trend while keeping the sense of geographical diversity so essential to world-building. Is there a single aspect of its streamlining that stands out to you?

CT: I’d say more of a methodology than a specific element. Combat, economy, and culture are all exceedingly simple and easy to understand and command. The beating heart of Mare Nostrum is that these systems facilitate meaningful player interaction. From the really unique and stellar trade system to the simplistic combat, it’s about maneuvering around the other players at the table. This is game where you’re playing your opponents and not the mechanics.


CC: Very true. The impressively short and tight rules allow players to get right into the meat of the game without having to master a dozen different mechanics or turn phases, but it’s not reduced to the point of abstraction, thanks in large part to the recruitment of heroes and the construction of wonders, adding flavor to your Empire while they propel you to victory. Whether you’re pursuing a strategy of peace or war, economy or expansion, you’ll find an ancient hero to aid your cause.

CT: Yeah, the small inclusion of a randomized allotment of heroes and wonders you can buy every game adds variety and a touch of depth and exploration beyond the base structure. What’s interesting also is how these tie into the multiple paths to victory.

This is very much a pretty standard take turns building and moving about a board, but the game strips out a tech tree and instead focuses the paths of victory down several lanes. You can go for military conquest by sacking four cities, lead in the game’s culture/economy/military tracks which represent building and development, acquire five heroes/wonders, or build the mighty pyramids. All of these options feel distinct yet dovetail nicely into the core functions of the game and don’t feel tacked on in any way.

CC: Mare Nostrum: Empires is full of these simple tweaks to convention. For a five-player game, set up the board as usual. Four players? Slide the Leadership Board to the left, covering the eastern portion of the map. Three? Keep sliding until the Leadership and Heroes and Wonders Boards cover even more, creating a scalable playing field from the same core pieces. Sure, Egypt may have a bit more expansion room than the other empires with the four-player map, but for the most part it works very well.

You mentioned the multiple paths to victory, and the game’s balance creates many opportunities for strategic adjustment. By playing the other players, as you said, a shrewd leader can spot which path is open to them and which have been closed off by their rivals, with these options changing several times as the game progresses.


CT: Yes, that’s it: the feel of the game is very dynamic and lively. Many civilization games get bogged down and drawn out with a pace akin to their Sid Meier PC counterpart, but everything moves so quickly here that you must get up and running and in the fight. You can’t dawdle and this keeps the pressure present and introduces an element of tension similar to a race. You have to push forward even if someone else is standing in the way.

That synthesis of light rules framework with meaty interaction seals the deal on this one. It stands out as a war/Euro with bite and sophistication. Every single aspect has just enough detail to get the job done.

For instance, I personally love the light combat and feel as though it fits right in with the structure of the game. The depth again arises through forming defensive boundaries with fortresses and snaking triremes across the Mediterranean to bridge troops to vital locations. Inject negotiation and the trading phase and you got a heck of an experience.

CC: You’re exactly right. Combat offers players the opportunity to race across open ground, build a wall, break through an opponent’s defense, or sail around it, and its most complicated aspect is math involving Roman numerals.

Mare Nostrum: Empires takes all aspects of an epic civ game, strips away their excess to reveal an optimized core, and delivers…well, it just plain delivers. Take note, game developers. The fast and deep civilization grail has been found.


Comments

You must be logged in to post a comment.

click here to log in